REVIEW FOR [email protected]
Let me start by commending you on a wonderful performance. There's a lot to praise about this: your energy throughout, your time, intonation, technical ability on the alto, and leading the band throughout it all. Bravo!

Some of what I have to say gets into style preferences which is subjective, so I'll give you my thoughts and let you decide what to incorporate into your own musical personality. So permit me to nit pick!

You wrote about wanting to play "more interesting ideas". That is the goal for each of us and something great players do well. A lot of your improvisation consists of 16th note runs, especially after 2:03. What more interesting ideas could you express by creating more variety in your lines - specifically held notes or at least longer notes that could make for an interesting motif and motivic development? I like finding notes that are common across bars or chords. Consider concert D, especially over the G7/C7 bars. That note works well over much of the tune and creates an interesting color over various chords. You did play some note length variety in the section starting at :40. That was good. Just watch the notes you lean on like that concert Ab and Bb in the second time through that A section. Raising each of those a half step (to A and B) would sound more harmonically congruent.

But whether or not you do it as I described, variety adds interest. And that variety can be note length, articulation, playing deliberately outside of the harmony for a bit, or note range (which you mentioned). And I do understand your desire to finish with a flurry, but sometimes going out with a bang can be done without a lot of notes. (Of course a trombone player is suggesting that!)

You mentioned the ending so let's talk about your cadenza. First make sure you nail that suspended chord's harmony (you weren't quite in the chord) because that's your opportunity to make the contrast with the resolved last chord. You might plan beforehand what your last suspended note is and improvise your way of getting to it. To my ear, ending on B (the major third of the chord) is a weaker note that gets lost in the G major chord the band is playing than, say A, which has a little more personality on top of G major.

You mentioned playing more in the genre, but I think you did that well. That arrangement contains a bit of modern reharm off the basic changes, so it lends itself to playing the way you did. Again, this is subjective, but I could hear myself playing over this with lots of longer notes bending to squeeze out the emotion of the song. Consider the lyrics containing phrases like: "Sad as I can be", "Listen to me plead", "Crying all alone" and so on. It's not a happy tune!

But let me conclude by saying you played really well throughout. I am nit picking, but then again, I don't think you would have submitting this sample if you didn't want to hear my thoughts on taking your terrific rendition of Willow to another level. Keep up the excellent work!

Here is Richie explaining the use of common tones and how they provide more interest than what he describes as a completely vertical approach.

Richie Beirach talks about common tones

This doesn't directly relate to my feedback, but as an alto player, I thought you'd enjoy this short clip from Charles from our conversation about connecting ear to instrument.

Charles McPherson on developing the ear/brain connection

What did you hear from this?

Share what you heard in this playing — what stood out, what you recognized in yourself, what clicked.

Log in or join Jazz Circle to share what you heard.

Log in or join Jazz Circle

Keep going with Jazz Circle

Your classroom access has run its course. One payment keeps the full Circle — no monthly subscription.

Join the Jazz Circle for $149, for ever!

Keep Improvisation Savvy, Pocket Jazz, Jazz Master Savvy, Groovz Playground, and the Learning Library. This purchase never expires.

Continue with Jazz Circle for only $149

Keep Exploring
Music Savvy

Create your free Music Savvy account to keep exploring lessons, interviews, Groovz tracks, and ideas for becoming the improviser you want to be. (Psssst... you can be that player!)

First name is required.

Enter a valid email address.

Ready to Go Deeper?

You’ve explored Music Savvy. Now you can go deeper with full access to the things you’re most interested in.

Get Full Access to Improvisation Savvy

Go beyond this next lesson and get access to the entire course.

Get Improvisation Savvy

Or go all in with a Jazz Circle membership

Access to the Improvisation Savvy plus the Groovz Playground play-along tracks for practicing. Watch any interview from the complete library of greats like Ron Carter, Joe Lovano,Randy Brecker... Answer your questions within the Learning Library articles, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle

Play and practice with any of the Groovz Playground tracks.

Continue to explore all of these tracks to find those that inspire you to practice. Use the mood finder to find tracks based on their 'mood.'

Get Groovz Playground

Or go all in with Jazz Circle membership

Get all the Groovz Playground tracks, learn from the Improvisation Savvy course, and watch any of the 60+ interviews with a great player or teacher. Answer your questions within the Learning Library articles, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle

Get Full Access to Jazz Master Savvy

Continue to watch any of the interviews you want.

Get all the Jazz Master Savvy Interviews

Or go all in with Jazz Circle

Get the entire Jazz Master Savvy interview collection, the Improvisation Savvy course, and the Groovz Playground collection of play-along tracks. Answer your questions within the Learning Library articles, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle

Keep Exploring the Learning Library

Continue reading the ideas and insights inside the Music Savvy Learning Library.

Read from the entire Learning library, learn from the Improvisation Savvy course, and practice with any Groovz Playground play-along track. Watch any of the 60+ interviews with a great player or teacher, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle