REVIEW FOR MATTHEW CHAPPELL
You have a big strong command of the trombone. I'm guessing you also have good endurance. Your intonation is solid as well. All good to have for playing the horn well.

We all have our own style of playing, and I make sure not to dictate a particular style of performing or improvising. But you use the word "smooth" in describing how you want to play. So for that, let's look at your hard articulation and forceful sound. Consider many of the trombone legends and how they approach improvisation. JJ, Carl Fontana, Watrous, McChesney... They tend toward a lighter (quieter) approach. The reason is that playing lighter - especially for brass players - allows for more dexterity and a smoother style. It's hard to run with a heavy backpack!

Again, your personal style is what feels right to you. You have a very percussive approach that is very on top of the beat. An example is the phrase at 1:20. Notice how hard you attack those notes. You might be more satisfied by playing them lighter, more legato, and a bit less on top of the beat. Think of how Slide Hapton might play that phrase: still with a big sound, but with some ghosted notes, legato and a bit laid back. His would be a more traditional swinging style. The other advantage of a lighter approach would be that you could play longer phrases that could allow you to tell more interesting 'stories.'

Trombonist to trombonist, let's talk about how you hold your slide. Your slide movement is more stiff than I think a more flexible wrist movement would provide. Why does that matter? Because just like the harder more forceful articulation I mentioned reduces flexibility, so does the more rigid wrist movement. Bob McChesney demonstrates in the samples I provide the relationship between slide movement and the perception of pitch. Watch how he sounds like he is playing a scales while moving the slide in random positions. You don't need to be multi-tonguing to get the point of his demonstration. The take-away for you should be that precise slide position is less necessary as you flow through a series of various notes. The start and end are most important and will allow an easier expression of your jazz playing.

Do you practice Rochut etudes? One benefit of them is to develop a lighter articulation and connection of notes. Even the first phrase of Rochut #1 can be a challenging exercise to play smoothly and evenly with a light attack. I recommend putting that into your practicing. As extra jazz practice credit, play that phrase starting on random notes (keys).

I don't want to discourage you, however, because there are many good things going on in your playing and within this solo. One thing I really liked was the creative way you ended the solo, using the slide as a creative device. I think if you lightened your approach in places, you could express more emotional swinging dimensions by playing longer phrases and with more dynamic variety. But you are a strong player. Keep up the good work!

Nobody plays like Bob McChesney, but I think there's a valuable perspective to gain from hearing his view on how he developed his light style of fast playing.

Bob McChesney on his approach to articulation

Here's Bob demonstrating how the perception of accurate note placement does not depend on perfect (or sometimes even close) slide positions.

Bob McChesney on tongue/slide coordination

The point Dave makes here is the importance of listening to others as a way of developing swing. Now, swing varies player to player. There's a big difference between say, Oscal Peterson and Bill Evans in their swing feel. As I encourage you to lay back a bit so that your playing is not so on top of the beat, listen to Oscar and Dexter and Slide Hampton. Slide is a good model. Listen to how he swings with ghosted notes and smooth articulation.

Dave Liebman on developing a swing feel

What did you hear from this?

Share what you heard in this playing — what stood out, what you recognized in yourself, what clicked.

Log in or join Jazz Circle to share what you heard.

Log in or join Jazz Circle

Keep going with Jazz Circle

Your classroom access has run its course. One payment keeps the full Circle — no monthly subscription.

Join the Jazz Circle for $149, for ever!

Keep Improvisation Savvy, Pocket Jazz, Jazz Master Savvy, Groovz Playground, and the Learning Library. This purchase never expires.

Continue with Jazz Circle for only $149

Keep Exploring
Music Savvy

Create your free Music Savvy account to keep exploring lessons, interviews, Groovz tracks, and ideas for becoming the improviser you want to be. (Psssst... you can be that player!)

First name is required.

Enter a valid email address.

Ready to Go Deeper?

You’ve explored Music Savvy. Now you can go deeper with full access to the things you’re most interested in.

Get Full Access to Improvisation Savvy

Go beyond this next lesson and get access to the entire course.

Get Improvisation Savvy

Or go all in with a Jazz Circle membership

Access to the Improvisation Savvy plus the Groovz Playground play-along tracks for practicing. Watch any interview from the complete library of greats like Ron Carter, Joe Lovano,Randy Brecker... Answer your questions within the Learning Library articles, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle

Play and practice with any of the Groovz Playground tracks.

Continue to explore all of these tracks to find those that inspire you to practice. Use the mood finder to find tracks based on their 'mood.'

Get Groovz Playground

Or go all in with Jazz Circle membership

Get all the Groovz Playground tracks, learn from the Improvisation Savvy course, and watch any of the 60+ interviews with a great player or teacher. Answer your questions within the Learning Library articles, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle

Get Full Access to Jazz Master Savvy

Continue to watch any of the interviews you want.

Get all the Jazz Master Savvy Interviews

Or go all in with Jazz Circle

Get the entire Jazz Master Savvy interview collection, the Improvisation Savvy course, and the Groovz Playground collection of play-along tracks. Answer your questions within the Learning Library articles, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle

Keep Exploring the Learning Library

Continue reading the ideas and insights inside the Music Savvy Learning Library.

Read from the entire Learning library, learn from the Improvisation Savvy course, and practice with any Groovz Playground play-along track. Watch any of the 60+ interviews with a great player or teacher, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle