REVIEW FOR REGGIE
You wrote that you'd like to understand the changes better, but it sounds like you are playing well within the changes of the tune. I'm not sure what you think you are missing there. For the most part, I think your time is pretty solid, which is something with which a lot of players struggle. Good job there! Plus, I like the tune. Solid melody and performance by the group.

Let's zero in on your improvisation. Overall, you have good energy and are pretty solidly within the changes. My question for you is: what would you sound like if you weren't as focused on the scales and fast notes - specifically the minor pentatonic scales? That's your go-to pattern, both at the start of the solo and the beginning of the bridge. That G minor pentatonic is well-rehearsed and comfortable under your fingers, so I understand why you use it. What is the alternative? MELODY.

As one example, listen to Herbie play Cantaloupe Island on the Empyrean Isles album. Herbie starts his solo just before the 3-minute mark. Herbie has the chops to start his solo with a flurry of F minor pentatonic scale patterns, but instead he plays a simple melodic phrase, and then plays pretty much the same phrase over the Db7 which reinforces the melodic power of that simple phrase. He then creates a variation on those notes. He does something similar when the form starts again. Notice that Herbie uses an economy of notes throughout his solo. He's playing simple phrases with variations. When he plays faster, those fast notes are like ornamentation, not the focus of the solo. He's using space to 'frame' his phrases. That use of space that frames good melodic phrases and variations is what produces quality music that your listener will appreciate.

Your goal is not to sound like Herbie, me, or anyone else. The goal is to improvise engaging music that is satisfying to your and your audience. Learning the theory of this music is beneficial, but my advice is to worry less about 'understanding changes better' and more about listening to the music inside you and reflecting that on the piano. You have the chops and you hear the time. Now, use those abilities and focus more on building/improvising music than relying on the flash of fast scale patterns.

Hear the points I made above within Herbie's solo

Cantaloupe Island

This is a clip of Richie Beirach talking about the use of motivic development in the context of modal playing. Autumn Drive is not modal, but it does have a slower harmonic progression. Regardless, Richie's point reinforces what I said about Herbie's approach to the Cantaloupe Island solo.

Richie Beirach on motivic development

Finding one's inner musical voice is the journey we are all on. It is the source of meaningful musical phrases rather than solos filled with memorized licks and scale patterns. Here is piano great George Cables talking about that journey.

George Cables on finding one's musical voice

What did you hear from this?

Share what you heard in this playing — what stood out, what you recognized in yourself, what clicked.

Log in or join Jazz Circle to share what you heard.

Log in or join Jazz Circle

Keep going with Jazz Circle

Your classroom access has run its course. One payment keeps the full Circle — no monthly subscription.

Join the Jazz Circle for $149, for ever!

Keep Improvisation Savvy, Pocket Jazz, Jazz Master Savvy, Groovz Playground, and the Learning Library. This purchase never expires.

Continue with Jazz Circle for only $149

Keep Exploring
Music Savvy

Create your free Music Savvy account to keep exploring lessons, interviews, Groovz tracks, and ideas for becoming the improviser you want to be. (Psssst... you can be that player!)

First name is required.

Enter a valid email address.

Ready to Go Deeper?

You’ve explored Music Savvy. Now you can go deeper with full access to the things you’re most interested in.

Get Full Access to Improvisation Savvy

Go beyond this next lesson and get access to the entire course.

Get Improvisation Savvy

Or go all in with a Jazz Circle membership

Access to the Improvisation Savvy plus the Groovz Playground play-along tracks for practicing. Watch any interview from the complete library of greats like Ron Carter, Joe Lovano,Randy Brecker... Answer your questions within the Learning Library articles, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle

Play and practice with any of the Groovz Playground tracks.

Continue to explore all of these tracks to find those that inspire you to practice. Use the mood finder to find tracks based on their 'mood.'

Get Groovz Playground

Or go all in with Jazz Circle membership

Get all the Groovz Playground tracks, learn from the Improvisation Savvy course, and watch any of the 60+ interviews with a great player or teacher. Answer your questions within the Learning Library articles, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle

Get Full Access to Jazz Master Savvy

Continue to watch any of the interviews you want.

Get all the Jazz Master Savvy Interviews

Or go all in with Jazz Circle

Get the entire Jazz Master Savvy interview collection, the Improvisation Savvy course, and the Groovz Playground collection of play-along tracks. Answer your questions within the Learning Library articles, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle

Keep Exploring the Learning Library

Continue reading the ideas and insights inside the Music Savvy Learning Library.

Read from the entire Learning library, learn from the Improvisation Savvy course, and practice with any Groovz Playground play-along track. Watch any of the 60+ interviews with a great player or teacher, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle