Learning Library

What Is Swing?

Not a rhythmic formula. Not a notation convention. Swing begins with how we hear rhythm.

Michael Lake 15 min read

If you've spent any time learning jazz, you've probably heard swing explained as a way of playing eighth notes. They're not straight, they're not exactly triplets. They fall somewhere in between.

There's some truth to that. But it doesn't explain why one musician can play a line that feels alive while another plays the same notes with the same rhythm that falls flat.

You know swing when you hear it.

Listen to Oscar Peterson, Count Basie, Cannonball Adderley, or Ella Fitzgerald. Before you analyze a single note, your foot is tapping. Your head starts bobbing. You smile. The music invites you in with an effortless momentum that's futile to resist.

That's swing.

Not a rhythmic formula. Not a notation convention. A musical feeling.

The challenge is that feelings are much harder to define than note values. It's a lot easier to draw a triplet with one note accented on a page than to explain why one performance grooves while another leaves you completely unmoved.

That's why so many explanations of swing miss the point. They describe what the notes look like instead of what the music does.

Why Swing Is So Hard to Explain

One of the reasons swing has been so difficult to define is that it can't be fully captured on a page. We can write the notes, notate the rhythms, and even indicate articulations and accents, but the notation is only a blueprint. The life of the music is in the performance.

Think about Oscar Peterson. Before you notice a single chord substitution or admire his technical brilliance, you're drawn in by his energy. Your foot starts tapping. Your head begins to move. You feel an irresistible sense of joy that makes the music seem to dance.

Now imagine trying to explain exactly why that happens.

You could measure the length of every eighth note, analyze where he places each phrase, and record every accent and articulation. You could fill pages with observations about timing and dynamics. Another pianist could reproduce those measurements with remarkable accuracy but fail to create the same feeling.

Swing isn't the accuracy of those measurements. They describe what happened, but they don't explain why the performance feels alive.

Swing Begins Before the First Note

The more I've thought about swing, the more convinced I've become that it doesn't begin with what we play. It begins with what we hear.

When I was in college, I studied classical trombone with a terrific teacher named Gail Wilson. My lessons weren't about jazz. They were about developing my trombone technique using the classical exercises and etudes.

I remember playing the week's etude for Gail, and hearing him say:

"Stop swinging the phrases!"

I didn't think I was swinging. I wasn't hearing jazz or trying to make the music sound hip. I was just playing the music the way I heard it.

Those experiences have stayed with me my whole life. They reveal an important insight: swing isn't something you decide to add to the music. By the time you play a phrase, it's either already there or it isn't. Swing comes from how you hear rhythm, and that shapes your musical lines.

That's also why every great jazz musician swings differently. Oscar Peterson's rhythmic feel is unmistakably his own. So is Bill Evans' swing. Yet their playing has completely different characters. They aren't following two different swing formulas. They're expressing their two different musical personalities.

If swing were simply a matter of playing the "correct" rhythmic pattern, great jazz musicians would sound alike. Instead, each one reveals a unique way of hearing rhythm.

So perhaps we've been asking the wrong question. Instead of asking, "How do I add swing to my playing?" maybe we should be asking, "How do great musicians hear rhythm?"

How Great Musicians Hear Rhythm

So how do great jazz musicians hear rhythm differently? They hear movement.

Beginning players give every note about the same importance. The notes arrive one after another, each occupying its assigned place in the measure. The rhythm is technically correct, but it doesn't seem to go anywhere.

Great jazz musicians hear something very different.

Some notes lean into the next beat. Others create a moment of tension before they resolve. Some notes ask a question. Others answer it. Some are meant to stand out, and others simply lead to the next idea. Instead of hearing a string of individual notes, they hear a moving musical line with attitude.

That's why two musicians can play the same rhythm and create completely different results. One is reproducing a pattern of notes. The other is shaping a musical thought.

I think that's one of the reasons swing is so difficult to teach. We naturally try to explain it by describing what the notes are doing. But what we're really hearing is how one note relates to the next. Swing isn't found in isolated notes. It emerges from the relationships between them.

So, What Is Swing?

Swing isn't a mathamatical ratio between two eighth notes. It isn't magic dust you sprinkle on top of a phrase after you've chosen the notes. And it sure isn't something that can be reduced to a formula.

Swing is what happens when musical ideas are played with a rhythmic freedom that makes the music feel like a conversation.

It's the reason your foot starts tapping before you realize it. It's the reason a great solo seems to invite you in from one phrase to the next. It's the feeling that makes you smile, nod your head, and become part of the performance.

Every great jazz musician arrives there differently. Oscar Peterson doesn't swing like Bill Evans. Ella Fitzgerald doesn't swing like Eddie Jefferson. Yet they all create that same irresistible sense of movement because each hears rhythm in their deeply personal way.

Perhaps that's why swing has always been so seemingly impossible to define. It's not a defined rule. It's a language. You don't learn it by memorizing a definition. You develop it by listening, absorbing, and gradually changing the way you hear music.

Before swing becomes something you play, it has to become something you hear.

Continue Your Journey

Put It Into Practice

What Would Change If You Focused on What Matters Most?

Becoming a better jazz musician isn't just about how much you practice. It's about knowing where to focus your time, energy, and attention.

Written by a Grammy-nominated trombonist, Do More of What Matters Most helps you get clear about what you want and build your days around making it happen.

GET THE BOOK

The players you admire didn't get there by accident.

They knew why they played, what sound they were chasing, and how to protect time for it, even with busy lives.

Written by a Grammy-nominated trombonist, Do More of What Matters Most helps you get that same clarity and build your days around it to play as you imagine you can.

GET THE BOOK

Keep going with Jazz Circle

Your classroom access has run its course. One payment keeps the full Circle — no monthly subscription.

Join the Jazz Circle for $149, for ever!

Keep Improvisation Savvy, Pocket Jazz, Jazz Master Savvy, Groovz Playground, and the Learning Library. This purchase never expires.

Continue with Jazz Circle for only $149

Keep Exploring
Music Savvy

Create your free Music Savvy account to keep exploring lessons, interviews, Groovz tracks, and ideas for becoming the improviser you want to be. (Psssst... you can be that player!)

First name is required.

Enter a valid email address.

Ready to Go Deeper?

You’ve explored Music Savvy. Now you can go deeper with full access to the things you’re most interested in.

Get Full Access to Improvisation Savvy

Go beyond this next lesson and get access to the entire course.

Get Improvisation Savvy

Or go all in with a Jazz Circle membership

Access to the Improvisation Savvy plus the Groovz Playground play-along tracks for practicing. Watch any interview from the complete library of greats like Ron Carter, Joe Lovano,Randy Brecker... Answer your questions within the Learning Library articles, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle

Play and practice with any of the Groovz Playground tracks.

Continue to explore all of these tracks to find those that inspire you to practice. Use the mood finder to find tracks based on their 'mood.'

Get Groovz Playground

Or go all in with Jazz Circle membership

Get all the Groovz Playground tracks, learn from the Improvisation Savvy course, and watch any of the 60+ interviews with a great player or teacher. Answer your questions within the Learning Library articles, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle

Get Full Access to Jazz Master Savvy

Continue to watch any of the interviews you want.

Get all the Jazz Master Savvy Interviews

Or go all in with Jazz Circle

Get the entire Jazz Master Savvy interview collection, the Improvisation Savvy course, and the Groovz Playground collection of play-along tracks. Answer your questions within the Learning Library articles, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle

Keep Exploring the Learning Library

Continue reading the ideas and insights inside the Music Savvy Learning Library.

Read from the entire Learning library, learn from the Improvisation Savvy course, and practice with any Groovz Playground play-along track. Watch any of the 60+ interviews with a great player or teacher, and check out everything else within the Jazz Circle membership.

Join Jazz Circle