Our quest for popularity

“The audience comes last. I’m not making it for them. I’m making it for me. And it turns out that when you make something truly for yourself, you’re doing the best thing you possibly can for the audience.”

That was spoken by the legendary rock music producer Rick Rubin, about his new book, The Creative Act: A Way of Being. 

That resonates with me because I’ve never been capable of creating something for the purpose of it being popular with, as Rubin labels it, the faceless masses. That’s a good thing for me I suppose since I play trombone (“Do they even make those any more?”) and I enjoy crafting eclectic sonic  soundscapes under curious visuals!

I’ve lately had a conversation with several people that goes something like this: I think the music I’m putting out there is really good but it is NOT catching fire the way I expect/want it to. Some of these players are bothered by their lack of popularity and others are at peace with the size of their small but enthusiastic audience. I fall into the latter category.

If you ponder this for yourself, into which category do you fall? I hope you are at peace with the size and return on your particular audience but I think that most are not. In the comments below, I’d really like to hear from you on this.

Show me the money

Yes, life requires money. And unless you are a trust fund baby, money requires earning it in some capacity. But in making that living, is your focus on maximizing income or is it in maximizing the satisfaction you receive from your art–performing, teaching, producing, painting, writing, recording, etc.?” Rubin contends that your best chance for success comes from pleasing yourself first.

I recently heard a moderately well-known Hollywood actor reflect on finally making the money he always wanted, but now at this point in his life, he’s never been less happy/satisfied. How did this come to be? Did he accept roles mainly for the money or for the dreamed-of popularity? (He actually said something like, “I’m now less interested in being alive.”) I don’t know, but his decisions somewhere along his career were not likely motivated by his fundamental core values.

But Mike, I didn’t become a musician in order to get rich–like that actor did.” No, but are your career  choices geared in some fundamental way toward dollars or some other currency like social likes, views, followers, or fame? Those things aren’t bad as a result of your authentic art, they are only if they are the primary motivation to get out of bed every morning and work hard. Think about your underlying motivation. How is that steering your artistic efforts or career choices?

I’d rather be hated for who I am than loved for who I am not.

– Kurt Cobain

What can you do?

If you feel that your quest for popularity, likes, shares, etc. might be driving you to do gigs, recording, videos, and social posting that is not authentic, should you right the ship?

Try an experiment. Purposefully create something with no concern for an audience. What music or other artistic activity could you create that is wholly satisfying to you? You might be surprised how much of an audience values your authenticity. Yes, you’ll have to allow them to find you, but they will be your raving fans. 1,000 of those is worth much more than 100,000 viewers who mindlessly hit the follow button without giving it much attention. Back to your motivation… Did Coltrane record A Love Supreme because he thought it would make him wealthy?  

In fact Richie Beirach and I wrote a book on this very topic: Great Art and Commercial Success

I recently started an experiment on Instagram. I’d never been on Instagram, mainly because my professional efforts were never geared toward visuals, and I had no interest in posting a pic of what I ate for lunch today or of my pals and I out drinking too much. 

But as I’ve built my skills at generating AI art, I now have an outlet for storing these strange and wonderful images. So one month and 94 posts later I have a whopping 22 followers and a small handful of “likes”. But by posting only those images that I’m most proud of, I have the best possible chance of building a following. Go ahead and follow me if you like what I’m creating, I’m just not posting things geared to gaining followers. This leads to the rhetorical question, why would anyone buy faceless social followers?

Back to Rick Rubin. We know that having a bigger enthusiastic audience often translates into more money, assuming you know how to monetize your audience. The question is, how do you best grow that enthusiastic audience as big as possible? The point I’m laboring to make is that I believe it comes from holding true to your authentic artistic vision rather than chasing after likes, views, or other false Gods of popularity. 

Consider this thought experiment: even if you gained success by pandering to an audience, would the additional money/fame make you a happier person? Would you end up years from now confident  that you left nothing of your artistic abilities on the table when the game was over? Is that important to you?

2 thoughts on “Our quest for popularity”

  1. “First, I play for myself, then the other musicians, and then the audience, in that order.” – Dizzy Gillespie

  2. great article, thanks! I feel like I have been authentic in my creative output so far but since moving to NYC I started thinking about what I could do different to get certain gigs for example… I can see now that this is the wrong way to go and will nip these thoughts in the bud.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Michael Lake

Michael Lake

Trombonist, author, marketer, & tech guy

Share this post…

Most recent

Perfection in practicing

I recently published a new video in my series on my AI called Jazz Master Chat. The video asked for tips on improving the effectiveness of practicing a musical instrument.

Read More »

The devil in the chip

More and more often I see musicians hating on artificial intelligence. I think the same can be said for artists in general. And I think that is a shame given

Read More »
Most popular

This is just a fake book example for the type of website I can build for you. Just trying to use a little humor here!